The Anarchy transports players to 12th-century England during a tumultuous civil war following King Henry I’s death.
Players take on the roles of nobles loyal to King Stephen, tasked with managing their fiefdoms, fortifying castles, training soldiers, and expanding influence while defending against the encroaching forces of Empress Matilda.
At its heart, The Anarchy is a heavy flip-and-write game with deep Euro-style mechanics. Over five intense rounds, players use the results from flipped cards (showing specific worker types) to assign actions on their personal boards, racing to build the most fortified and prosperous domain while managing threats, public sentiment, and personal ambitions.
How the Game Works
Each round, players draw a set of worker cards representing various actions—such as gathering resources, fortifying defenses, training troops, or constructing buildings. With these, they fill in boxes and tracks on their personal player sheets, advancing multiple interconnected systems.
Here’s what you’re focusing on during play:
Castle Building: Strengthening your walls, keeps, and defenses is critical. Castles not only protect your domain from sieges but also unlock additional bonuses and scoring opportunities.
Defending and Attacking: Players must balance developing their infrastructure with preparing for enemy sieges and raids. Investing in military strength is essential, as undefended domains will suffer heavy penalties.
Resource Management: Carefully balance collecting stone, wood, gold, and soldiers. Many actions rely on spending these resources efficiently, and overcommitting to one strategy can leave you vulnerable in others.
Influence and Reputation: Building favor in the court (measured in Bravery, Loyalty, and Influence) contributes to your final score—but only if you also manage Discontent. If your peasants get too angry, you’ll lose precious points.
Solo and Campaign Play: The solo mode offers unique challenges and campaigns with escalating difficulty. Players face a progressively harsher AI opponent and must adapt their strategies to survive.
At the end of five rounds, players tally points from various sources: castle fortifications, military victories, courtly influence, completed objectives, and bonuses from secret goals.
Pros
- Deep Strategic Gameplay: The Anarchy offers a rich blend of resource management, castle defense, and offensive strategies. Players must carefully plan their actions to optimize their domains and respond to evolving threats.
- Engaging Solo Mode: The game includes a robust solo mode with a campaign book, providing varied scenarios and challenges that enhance replayability.
- High-Quality Components: The game features detailed artwork by Sam Phillips and well-designed components, contributing to an immersive thematic experience.
Cons
- Steep Learning Curve: With a 40-page rulebook and complex mechanics, The Anarchy may be daunting for new players or those unfamiliar with heavy Euro-style games.
- Potential for Analysis Paralysis: The depth of strategic options can lead to longer decision times, especially in multiplayer settings, potentially affecting game flow.
- Limited Player Interaction: While players compete for resources and objectives, direct interaction is minimal, which may not appeal to those seeking more confrontational gameplay.
Comparison to Similar Games
- Hadrian’s Wall: As a spiritual successor, The Anarchy builds upon the flip-and-write mechanics of Hadrian’s Wall, introducing more complexity and thematic depth.
- Roll-and-Write Games: Compared to lighter roll-and-write games, The Anarchy offers a more intricate and strategic experience, appealing to players who enjoy heavier Eurogames.
Final Thoughts
The Anarchy stands out as a complex and rewarding game that successfully combines flip-and-write mechanics with deep strategic elements. Its rich theme, engaging solo mode, and high-quality components make it a compelling choice for experienced gamers seeking a challenging experience. However, its complexity and potential for longer playtimes may not suit all players.
And remember, Frontline Gaming sells gaming products at a discount, every day in their webcart!
