Gloomhaven is an epic cooperative dungeon-crawler set in a richly imagined dark fantasy world. As a group of mercenaries with distinct abilities and motivations, you’ll navigate a branching narrative, battling monsters, exploring mysterious locations, and making choices that shape the unfolding story. What sets Gloomhaven apart is its emphasis on tactical combat and long-term campaign progression, where character growth and resource management are just as critical as winning individual scenarios.
Each session unfolds as a scenario, typically a combat-heavy encounter on a modular map. What lies beyond that, though, is a legacy-style experience: the world evolves, new locations are unlocked, and player decisions carry lasting consequences. The gameplay revolves around managing your character’s unique deck of action cards, combining clever tactics with careful planning to achieve victory while conserving resources for future battles.
Pros:
- Deep, Tactical Combat: Gloomhaven’s card-driven system offers a highly satisfying blend of strategic depth and player choice. Each character’s deck is tailored to their abilities, and the need to carefully manage stamina, movement, and attacks ensures every turn is an engaging puzzle.
- Rich Campaign and Narrative: With 95+ scenarios and branching storylines, the campaign provides an immersive experience with hours of replayability. Players get to craft their own journey, with meaningful decisions impacting the world and future scenarios.
- Diverse Characters and Classes: The roster of characters is both varied and unique, with distinct playstyles. Unlocking new classes feels rewarding and adds fresh challenges, encouraging experimentation and strategic growth.
- Cooperative Synergy: Effective teamwork is essential, as the game punishes lone-wolf behavior. This fosters a strong sense of camaraderie and encourages players to work together to overcome increasingly difficult encounters.
- Exceptional Production Quality: From the detailed miniatures to the sprawling world map and countless tokens, the game offers a tactile and visually appealing experience.
- Replayability: The modular scenarios, branching paths, and varied characters make each campaign feel different, offering tons of replay value even after the initial run.
Cons:
- Overwhelming Complexity for New Players: Gloomhaven is a massive undertaking, and the rulebook can be intimidating. New players may struggle with the game’s steep learning curve, from understanding mechanics to managing the numerous components.
- Lengthy Setup and Playtime: Setting up scenarios can be time-consuming due to the sheer number of components. Scenarios often run 2-3 hours, which can be daunting for players with limited time.
- Campaign Commitment: While the campaign is a strength, it’s also a barrier for groups that can’t commit to regular sessions. Dropping in and out mid-campaign can disrupt the flow and cohesion of the story.
- Card Management Fatigue: The stamina system, where action cards are “spent” and can’t be reused easily, adds tension but can feel restrictive, especially for players unused to such mechanics. Some may find it frustrating to be forced to retire their character as part of the campaign’s progression.
- Solo Play Can Be Tedious: Although solo mode is possible, managing multiple characters alone can feel more like bookkeeping than an enjoyable adventure.
Comparison to Similar Games:
- Descent: Legends of the Dark: Like Gloomhaven, Descent offers a rich campaign and dungeon-crawling experience, but it incorporates an app to streamline storytelling and scenario management. Descent’s lighter rules and focus on narrative make it more accessible, though it sacrifices some of the depth that makes Gloomhaven so engaging.
- Frosthaven: As a direct sequel to Gloomhaven, Frosthaven builds on its predecessor with even more content, added crafting mechanics, and greater scenario variety. Frosthaven is the natural choice for players who’ve mastered Gloomhaven and want to explore new challenges.
- Mage Knight: Mage Knight offers a similarly complex fantasy experience but focuses more on deck-building and exploration. Mage Knight is better suited for solo players or small groups who enjoy a sandbox-style adventure, while Gloomhaven shines in cooperative settings.
- Arkham Horror: The Card Game: For players who enjoy deep narrative and cooperative play, Arkham Horror LCG offers similar decision-making and story-driven scenarios but uses a compact, card-based format. Arkham Horror is faster and more portable but lacks the tactical combat and world-building scale of Gloomhaven.
- Aeon’s End: Both games involve cooperative gameplay and deck management, but Aeon’s End is more focused on fighting through waves of enemies in a quicker, more streamlined fashion. Gloomhaven is far more robust, while Aeon’s End offers shorter, faster-paced experiences.
Summary:
Gloomhaven is a towering achievement in board game design, offering an unparalleled blend of tactical combat, narrative depth, and campaign longevity. Its scale and complexity reward dedicated players who enjoy immersive experiences, intricate mechanics, and working as a team to tackle tough challenges. However, its demanding setup, rulebook, and time commitment make it less approachable for casual gamers or those looking for a quick pick-up-and-play experience.
For those willing to dive in, Gloomhaven delivers some of the most satisfying moments in tabletop gaming. It’s not just about the journey through dark dungeons and sprawling maps—it’s about how you and your group overcome each obstacle together, adapt your strategies, and watch your characters grow. Despite its few flaws, it’s a masterpiece that sets the gold standard for cooperative, campaign-driven board games. If you love tactical decision-making and storytelling, Gloomhaven deserves a place on your table.
And remember, Frontline Gaming sells gaming products at a discount, every day in their webcart!
